The Forgotten Founding Father

Noah Webster's Obsession and the Creation of an American Culture

The Forgotten Founding Father

Order now at your favorite bookseller:

Amazon⬈ Barnes and Noble⬈

Noah Webster (1758–1843) was more than just America’s greatest lexicographer. He was also a Founding Father who helped define American culture. In 1783, he published the first edition of his legendary spelling book, which would teach five generations of Americans how to read. A leading Federalist, who was a confidant of both George Washington and Alexander Hamilton, Webster was in Philadelphia during the Constitutional Convention where he wrote a highly influential essay on behalf of the nation’s founding document. During the greater part of the 1790s, he edited American Minerva, New York City’s first daily newspaper. A dedicated public servant, he served as a state rep in both Connecticut and Massachusetts. “America’s pedagogue” was also a founder of Amherst College—he was an early president of the college’s Board of Trustees.

In 1798, the 1778 Yale grad moved back to New Haven with his family—he and his wife Rebecca Greenleaf would raise seven children—to begin his dictionary. Having made a fortune from his publishing ventures, Webster could afford to follow his heart. The first edition of his American Dictionary of the English Language was published in 1828. He would continue working on revisions until the day he died. In contrast to his predecessor, the renowned British wordsmith Samuel Johnson, who famously opined, “No man but a blockhead ever wrote, except for money,” Webster loved compiling and defining words more than just about anything else. This obsession, which was instrumental in helping a high-strung genius live an amazingly vibrant life, ended up giving America a language of its own.

The Author

Author Photo

Joshua C. Kendall is an award-winning journalist whose work has appeared in the New York Times, Los Angeles Times, Wall Street Journal, Psychology Today, and BusinessWeek, among other publications.

Click to see more⬈.

Q&As

I have a strong personal connection to Webster. Yale also inculcated in me a love of learning; after enjoying a dose of heady intellectual life in New Haven, I too faced the challenge of figuring out how to establish myself as a writer. When Webster turned twenty, his father handed him an $8 bill, which, during the hyperinflation of 1778, was nearly worthless. The bedraggled Hartford farmer then proceeded to inform his son that he was “on his own;” as Webster later put it in his memoir, he immediately “felt cast upon the world.” A little more than 200 Yale graduations later, my father, a hard-charging Wall Street exec, also failed to encourage my literary aspirations. As America’s first freelance writer—and one of its most successful—Webster has been a frequent source of inspiration. While most previous biographies have painted Webster as an American saint, I was interested in capturing his complex personality. He was a bundle of contradictions. Loner and accomplished networker. Revolutionary and reactionary. Womanizer and prig. Given that this non-stop writer kept a lively diary, I was excited by the chance to get inside his head and to show what made him tick.

Before beginning the research, which eventually led me to about twenty archive libraries up and down the East Coast, I had assumed that Webster was just a word-nerd who sequestered himself in his sand-lined study for decades to labor on the dictionary. I was surprised to discover that his magnum opus—the American Dictionary, first published in 1828—constituted the last act of a long career dedicated to both words and public service. By then, he was a national celebrity who had already shaped many aspects of American culture, ranging from education, science, and journalism to language and the very nature of our political institutions.

Webster attended college during the early years of the War for Independence; the summer before his senior year, he fought at the Battle of Saratoga. At Yale, he came under the influence of a young professor, Timothy Dwight—later the college’s president—who impressed upon him the need for Americans to unite behind a national identity. For the rest of his life, Webster urged Americans to think of themselves as Americans rather than as residents of a particular state or as immigrants tied to their country of origin. This fierce pride in all things American was the thread that linked all of his work. And even though he was at least fifteen years younger than most of the key Founders, he influenced them—rather than the other way around. As I describe in the prologue, at just twenty-six years old, he gave George Washington himself a civic lesson. When Washington told Webster that he had reached out to a friend in Scotland to find a tutor for his step-grandchildren, the young writer was aghast, noting that we should not look to Europe for our teachers. “America,” Webster insisted, “must be as independent in literature as she is in politics, as famous for arts as for arms.”

Webster was quite open in his diary and letters about his inner turmoil. While he lived in a pre-psychological age—long before the advent of the DSM, psychiatry’s massive diagnostic manual—he frequently used words like “depression,” “anxiety,” and “nervous affections” to describe his mental state. As I suggest, a modern-day psychologist might be inclined to diagnose him with obsessive-compulsive personality disorder (OCPD). While this condition is related to obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), it’s not the same. Unlike those with OCD, who often become incapacitated by their anxiety—for example, feeling compelled to check dozens of times whether they turned off the stove—people with OCPD typically function “better than well.” Webster’s obsessionality gave him the focus to devote endless hours to compiling and defining words. And while he lived a full and vibrant life, his inflexibility—stubbornness and a lack of empathy being hallmarks of this character disorder—took a toll on his wife and seven children. As therapists know all too well, domineering obsessionals often drive other family members to seek psychiatric treatment.

While Webster’s chronic anxiety made it difficult for him to connect with other people, he had a remarkable knack for connecting with the reader. His legendary American Spelling Book, which essentially taught reading rather than spelling, was user-friendly; it communicated the nuts and bolts of English in a manner that children could easily understand. While Webster made an enormous amount of money from the book — in 1816, he landed America’s first blockbuster book deal which promised him $ 42,000 over a 14-year period — he could have made even more. What caused his money troubles was that at the age of forty, he retired so that he could devote himself full-time to his dictionary. And because he was so dependent on the income from his speller, he didn’t strike hard bargains with his publishers. Thus, a year after signing that hefty contract, he caved in and asked for all the money upfront, settling for a total of $ 23,000.

Roget and Webster had a similar make-up; both men felt more comfortable in the company of words rather than people. Organizing the English language was for both this Founding Father and this Victorian physician a form of therapy, which provided an emotional anchor. Surprisingly, though both lexicographers were enormously gifted wordsmiths, each man lacked a literary sensibility. Unlike Samuel Johnson, who published the first great English dictionary in 1755, neither Webster nor Roget cared much for poetry, fiction or drama. While not a medical school graduate like Roget, Webster was also more at home in the world of science — right before starting the dictionary, he polished off a 1000-page treatise on epidemiology. Their careers ran on parallel tracks. Both men had expensive tastes and tried to solidify their finances in the same way — by finding a rich wife. “When you marry,” Webster advised his children, “look out for the stock.” And Roget’s Thesaurus, like Webster’s Dictionary, was also a retirement project. Roget started it in earnest at the age of 73 after he had both given up his medical practice and resigned from his lofty position as Secretary of the Royal Society, England’s foremost scientific organization.

In 1782, when Webster finished his speller, the Articles of Confederation were still the law of the land. To protect his asset, he became the father of American copyright law; he personally went to all the thirteen state capitals to ensure passage of the requisite legislation. His other early achievements include cranking out pamphlets in support of the Constitution. In 1785, he published “Sketches of American Policy,” which argued for the need for a stronger central government by famously noting that “our union is but a name and our confederation a web.” Several years later, at the behest of George Washington, he became the editor of New York City’s first daily newspaper, American Minerva. While living in Manhattan, the highly influential Federalist journalist began working on a series of books on “the yellow fever,” the plague that would terrorize America’s city dwellers throughout the 1790s. Thus, he also helped to give birth to modern public health research. In the early 1800s, he served as a state legislator in both Connecticut and Massachusetts. A progressive pedagogue, who championed both female education and public schools, he also helped to found Amherst College.

Webster began his dictionary in 1800 soon after he settled in the New Haven mansion formerly owned by Benedict Arnold. (Due to the stigma associated with living there, he got a good deal, paying only $2666.66). He would keep working on various versions of the dictionary until the day he died in 1843. Webster sought to make obsolete the works of both Samuel Johnson and Samuel Johnson, Jr. This other Johnson was no relation to the erudite Brit, but a school teacher from Connecticut who had compiled a small dictionary – most of the definitions were just one or two words – published in 1798. In 1806, Webster published his answer to Johnson Jr, his Compendious Dictionary of the English Language — compendious means brief — which was a warm-up exercise for the unabridged dictionary of 1828. To write his American Dictionary, Webster leaned on Johnson as well as on the major Latin-English Dictionary of the day by Robert Ainsworth. I examined the original manuscripts pages at several archives, including the Morgan Library and the New Haven Museum. At the New York Public Library, I also studied Webster’s copy of the 1799 version of Johnson’s Dictionary which he consulted frequently. Next to many of Johnson’s Shakespeare quotations, which were used to illustrate the meanings of words, Webster put a little black mark. In contrast to Johnson, Webster rarely cited Shakespeare. Instead he would insert “Shak” into the definitions of many dirty words such as “bastard” and “strumpet,” as if he were blaming the Bard of Avon himself for the world’s unwholesome characters. Webster’s hatred of Shakespeare dated back to his Yale days when undergraduates were fined for attending the theatre because drama was considered one step away from sex. While Webster’s text was less literary than Johnson’s, it was more scientific. He included thousands of new terms that had cropped up during the Enlightenment such as “phosphorescent” and “planetarium.” But Webster biggest improvement was not so much in comprehensiveness — though he defined 70,000 words as opposed to the 58,000 of the most recent edition of Johnson — as in precision. Webster transformed definitions from little more than lists of synonymous terms to tightly knit mini-essays, which highlighted fine distinctions. As James Murray, the editor of the OED once put it, Webster “was a born definer.”

Like his friend and idol, Benjamin Franklin, who once told him, “I have been all my life changing my opinions,” the argumentative Webster was often at war with himself. His constantly shifting positions on policy matters were a reflection of his tempestuous character. Webster might have made a good talking head on Cable TV. He liked to make inflammatory statements. As he entered middle-age, Webster insisted that no American should be allowed to vote until the age of 45. And Webster became particularly crotchety in old age which he defined as “an aristocracy resulting from God’s appointment.” (Though he often fulminated, Webster did have flashes of wit.) As he was about to turn eighty, he declared that he would rather be a bear and hibernate in winter than “be under the tyranny of our degenerate rulers,” describing Americans as “a degenerate and wicked people.”

None of the dictionaries that Webster worked on in his lifetime — even the unabridged edition of 1841, which he funded by mortgaging his home at the age of eighty — look like a modern-day dictionary. The English dictionary as we know it was born with the 1864 edition of Webster’s. Widely hailed as a masterpiece in its day, this version of The American Dictionary provided the template for everything that followed in both America and Britain, including the Oxford English Dictionary, whose first volume came out two decades later. This first major revision of Webster’s, which was edited by Noah Porter along with a team of lexicographers drawn largely from the Yale faculty, fixed the one major gaffe in Webster’s otherwise exemplary oeuvre. Webster’s etymologies were never more than wild guesswork. While philology — the systematic study of language — was still in its infancy during his lifetime, Webster’s self-absorption and stubbornness led him to ignore the important discoveries made by German scholars in the early 19th century. But with this one exception, Webster’s spirit infuses the contemporary dictionary; that’s why numerous publishers besides Merriam-Webster have slapped his name on the cover. Webster was the first lexicographer to turn his own examples into a central component of definitions. To explain morality, he noted, “We often admire the politeness of men whose morality we question.” Even more important, Webster was a fervent advocate for description over prescription, arguing that dictionaries should reflect language as it is, not how it ought to be. While this position was controversial for a century, it’s been the norm ever since the heyday of the late Phillip Gove, the editor of the massive Webster’s Third, published in 1961. Gove was the one who decided that “ain’t” was acceptable English. Likewise, in calling “refudiate” 2010’s word of the year, The New Oxford American Dictionary was also invoking the legacy of America’s greatest lexicographer.

Reviews

"Noah Webster forged American nationalism by creating an American language with his best-selling spelling-book and monumental dictionary. Joshua Kendall tells the story of his eventful life with narrative charm and psychological insight, exposing Webster’s faults and fights as well as his virtues and influence. Kendall enables the reader to place Webster in the context of both early republican political life and the development of lexicography.”
-Daniel Walker Howe, Pulitzer-Prize-winning author of What Hath God Wrought: The Transformation of America, 1815 – 1848
“As an Englishman I was not aware of Noah Webster other than as the compiler of America’s first dictionary; as a new American, I find my compatriots equally unaware! So I was delighted to learn about the life that he led in Joshua Kendall’s The Forgotten Founding Father. From his education at Yale and friendships formed with the dignitaries of the American Revolution – Washington and Franklin among them – to his speller for children, his pioneering journalism, and his passionate, unwavering belief in the unity and progress of the American republic, his biography offers a fascinating window on the formative years of the United States as a nation. An absorbing and instructive work!"
-Nigel Hamilton, New York Times bestselling author of JFK: Reckless Youth and Bill Clinton: An American Journey
“Noah Webster was quintessentially American–rugged, tenacious, confident, independent, and tremendously competitive. Joshua Kendall’s masterly biography shows just how these characteristics surfaced not only in Webster’s life but also in his books. This is a superb contribution to our understanding of America’s greatest lexicographer.”
-Bryan Garner, author, Garner’s Modern American Usage & editor, Black’s Law Dictionary
“Everyone knows Webster’s dictionary, but how many know Webster? Kendall’s portrait of America’s first great lexicographer is also the portrait of a scholar, an educator, a businessman, a politician, and a patriot, one who shaped the American language as he shaped the American nation. This lively biography — the most thoroughly researched and compellingly readable ever written – reveals Webster in all his complexity.”
-Jack Lynch, author of The Lexicographer’s Dilemma: The Evolution of ‘Proper’ English From Shakespeare to South Park
“Joshua Kendall’s biography of Noah Webster paints a rich portrait of an American original, a man who was determined to shape a new American culture as an educator, political advocate, newspaper publisher, and pathbreaking lexicographer. So obsessive that he counted the houses in every town he visited, Webster’s difficult personality was uniquely suited to creating a seminal dictionary almost entirely by himself.”
-David O. Stewart, author of Summer of 1787

Contact